In addition some of the previously discussed Chess Publishing methods just disappeared, which emphasizes the importance of one of the original requirements that it should not be dependent on another site.
Now let's first concentrate on the ChessFlash PGN viewer.
- It offers a chess board that shows the position after each move
- The moves are also shown
- Clicking on a move shows the position on the board after this move
- It doesn't offer autoplay
- Variations in the moves are possible
- It can deal with comments, but the comment at the start of a variation seems to be shown as belonging at the end of the previous move
- There is a kind of puzzle mode, but this doesn't show the moves after the right answer is given
- It is based on entering PGN
- I think that it is not necessary to copy and paste all kind of code. The Quick Publisher can be seen as an additional nice tool. The original requirement "Without the need to copy and paste all kind of code" is probably met
- It seems to depend on another site, but it will also be possible to host the player on your own site and a site like Google sites will do. However it will not be possible to limit ourselves to the Blogspot/Picasa combination.
- It loads rather slow, especially when you publish more chess games on the same page like you may frequently do on a blog-site). This can partly be solved by means of a show/hide wrapper, but I don't like to hide the content of my posts
- A separate PGN viewer is loaded for each chess game.
- It doesn't really feel integrated and the moves are always shown at the right side or below the board, but not around the chess board.
- The height and width is configurable, but the scrollbar at the right side remains.
So I think that the ChessFlash PGN viewer is a nice addition and I consider it as being better than Chesspublisher and Chesspastebin and the Chess Viewer Applet, but I still prefer the LT-PGN Editor and Viewer and certainly our own Blogspot Game Viewer, that has become a lot easier to use without the need for adding the coded moves.
Of course there may be other requirements (like selecting another chess set or board image) and some of the requirements above may not be important for your site so the order of chess game viewers may be different for you. It's rather easy to test them for yourself. Please share your findings in the comments.
No comments:
Post a Comment